by Jonathan McGaha | 28 March 2011 12:00 am
In today’s tough economic market, metal contractors bid more work and see more competition for a limited number of jobs. A few years ago, only 10 to 20 contractors competed on a bid; now 50 to 100 are bidding. The lowest bid often wins, so most bids have little or no profit margin.
Now, when a contractor wins a bid, the moment of joy quickly disappears with a nagging question:
What did I miss? If this sounds familiar, it’s time to take a look at the company’s estimating and
project management methods. Considering how critical it is to have detailed and accurate estimates, it’s easy to see the detractions of using antiquated methods of scale and paper or roller wheel and spreadsheets. It takes hours or days for a metal contractor to takeoff quantities by hand or guesstimate the time and material. Estimators may feel comfortable using these tools, but
manual methods cost contractors time and money.
Challenges of Manual Methods
The paper process requires expensive, bulky blueprints and messy piles of drawings, specifications,
estimates and alternates. If using spreadsheets, thousands of items need prices updated weekly. And what about change orders? Addendums or changes made during the bidding process are often
missed. When there are plan revisions, it can be a time-consuming process to re-takeoff the entire job. Project managers need to easily compare new plans to older ones, manage revisions and track changes. Manual methods make it difficult if not impossible to capitalize on every change order.
On any given job, manual estimating requires a contractor to spend 25 percent of his time doing
takeoff and 75 percent of his time determining labor and pricing. Contractors using manual methods
are more likely to make mistakes and have scarce time to consider
‘what-if’ scenarios and
negotiate a contract. Besides, how can a contractor negotiate without detailed breakdowns? In the
end, estimators waste time estimating jobs that they’ll have no chance of winning or working for
a profit. Further, estimators are probably spending way too much time doing basic math and not
enough time analyzing estimates to assess where more money can be made.
The highly competitive construction industry requires bids to be on target. Overbid and lose the work. Underbid and lose money. Precise takeoffs are critical to getting a project off on the right foot
and bring it in with a respectable profit margin. Manual estimating offers two other disadvantages.
If there is a disagreement between contractor and project owner, the one with the documentation
wins because the manual method lacks a tight audit trail. Also, contractors don’t know if they’re
making money until the project is complete. And without true historical cost data, a contractor has no
way to know what tasks they do best and on what jobs they should spend their time bidding.
Success comes down to mitigating risk and maximizing reward. To do so, metal contractors must perform accurate takeoffs, prepare detailed estimates and submit on-target bids. By implementing
takeoff and estimating software, a contractor will have the tools to streamline effort and help maintain a pipeline of opportunities.
Digitized Takeoff
Every profitable estimate starts with an accurate takeoff. By using software for takeoff-with digitized
or digital plans-contractors will experience significant time and cost savings. It can also help
eliminate costly errors and improve accuracy, helping contractors achieve better profit margins.
Some contractors still like to work with traditional blueprints. For those contractors, digitized
takeoff is a logical step toward improving speed and accuracy. Using this technology, estimators
simply lay the plans on a digitizer, set the scale, and point and click with a stylus pen. Estimators easily can measure lengths, areas and quantities of count items to within 1/1000th of an inch. Plus, contractors can efficiently build their estimate and quantify costs as they perform the takeoff, which eliminates redundant data entry and increases accuracy.
For contractors who want to eliminate the cost and hassle of paper blueprints, digital takeoff
technology allows them to download digital plan files from an online plan room, scan in plans or
upload from a CD-ROM, and then perform a takeoff quickly and accurately right on the computer
monitor. Digital takeoff also allows estimators to overlay addendum drawings, flag changes, and
reduce the possibility of missing the changes and additional costs.
Digital takeoff also lets contractors respond quickly when revisions arise. Because change orders can drastically impact project profitability, some contractors have seen their takeoff software pay for itself with a single won change order. That’s because when plan revisions are made with a digital
takeoff solution, contractors can instantly compare new plans to the older ones, allowing them to capitalize on every change order.
Leading digital takeoff solutions offer verification features that help contractors work faster and with precision, and provide comprehensive data to visual the job. For example, 3-D visual assemblies (VAs) provide comprehensive graphical checklists of individual cost items that are stored in a database and can be estimated together from one takeoff measurement. Visual assemblies are available to fit unique needs of different types of construction-metal contractors can take advantage of VAs for slab on metal deck, pre-engineered steel building, metal framing and more. By viewing all the components of a job in a lifelike image, estimators find it easy to determine if any items are missing or incorrect and have greater confidence that their takeoff is complete and accurate.
Beyond the Bid
Once a job is won, effectively managing the job is a whole other challenge. With automated takeoff and estimating tools, contractors can produce information required for project managers to successfully execute won jobs. Software bridges the gap between what is in the estimator’s head and what the project manager experiences on the job site.
Furthermore, the level of detail in the estimate provides the accounting and purchasing teams with
the necessary details for buying out the job. This helps to speed up the process and maintain accuracy, protect against purchasing more expensive materials than were estimated. A software solution that’s seamless from estimating through project management allows convenient access to details about proposals in process, bids, win-loss statistics and historical information, as well as provides centralized, critical, real-time information that helps to manage projects
for maximum efficiency.
Managing the Entire Life Cycle
In a market that requires frequent and accurate bidding for survival, the right technology solution
can give contractors a competitive edge. A comprehensive takeoff and estimating solution that
brings a team together, improves control, allows a contractor to manage with insight into productivity,
and helps them understand how to maximize profit on every job, will help them achieve maximum
profitability and success.
Mike Gillum is director of product management, estimating at Maxwell Systems, King of Prussia,
Pa. For more information on Maxwell Systems, visit www.maxwellsystems.com.
Source URL: https://www.metalconstructionnews.com/articles/increasing-profit-margins-with-better-bids/
Copyright ©2026 Metal Construction News unless otherwise noted.