by Jonathan McGaha | 25 October 2010 12:00 am
Construction is one of the nation’s largest employers, with more than 9.5 million people either on company payrolls or self-employed in the industry. The Bureau of Labor Statistics estimates that more than 2 million of those workers are foreign-born, which poses a major challenge for construction industry employers. That’s because, by law, each employer must check the identity and employment eligibility documents of every worker hired. The basic document for doing so is Form I-9, the Employment Eligibility Verification form issued by the Department of Homeland Security.
Criminal Prosecution
Construction industry companies are increasingly targeted for criminal prosecution if they “look the other way” when the hiring managers know, or should have known, that new hires presented false eligibility documents. For example, in February 2008, DHS enforcement officers arrested 57 illegal alien employees at a Lindon, Utah, metal fabrication plant. In addition, the company was criminally indicted on 10 counts of harboring illegal aliens, while its human resources director was indicted for encouraging or inducing illegal aliens to remain in the United States and subsequently pled guilty on two counts. More recently, a Houston company agreed to pay a $3 million fine and undertake substantial remediation of its practices after an investigation and raid. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the largest law enforcement agency in the DHS, is responsible for worksite compliance with federal immigration and customs laws and works in tandem with the FBI, U.S. attorneys nationwide, and state and local law enforcement. As ICE has grown in manpower and resources, its worksite enforcement initiatives have resulted in major investigations, arrests, criminal fines and-in some cases-prosecutions of companies and their HR managers, as well as employees and contractors. As of August 2008, ICE had made 1,022 criminal arrests in connection with worksite investigations in the current fiscal year, a 45-fold increase since 2001. Of those arrests, 116 involved owners, managers or human resources supervisors on such charges as knowingly hiring, harboring or transporting illegal aliens.
Verification Requirements
An ICE investigation may arise from an employee tip or from ICE intelligence about a company’s recruiting, hiring and I-9 processes. Whatever the source, every construction industry employer must prepare for an investigation by establishing clear policies on the legal requirements for recruiting, hiring and documentation of new employees. Form I-9 mandates that an employer examine the new hire’s evidence of identity and employment eligibility and record which documents the employee presented. Employers may not demand a specific document; instead, the worker chooses from the documents listed on the I-9. Employers must accept such documentation at face value and may not investigate further, unless the document does not seem “genuine” or it “appears” to belong to someone else. Requesting additional documents or information can result in claims of discrimination.
To date, federal law does not require all employers to “verify” that a new hire’s social security number is valid and belongs to the person hired. However, increasingly, state laws are requiring this additional step, using the government’s E-Verify online system to check the social security number and name combination of all new hires (after hiring, not before). Even though E-Verify cannot detect workers who present valid documents that were stolen or “borrowed” from the real owner, participation in the system can mitigate liability in the event of ICE action.
Contractors face an additional E-Verify complication. A June 2008 executive order by President George W. Bush required federal contractors to use E-Verify to determine that all new hires are eligible for employment in the United States and that all employees working on federal contracts-including current employees hired according to pre-existing rules and standards-are also eligible. The order did not clarify whether subcontractors and material suppliers were included or how employers can correct mistakes that the E-Verify system makes. Also unclear was how employers can avoid getting caught in the middle when workers can satisfy the pre-existing rules and standards-which Congress has written into the Immigration and Nationality Act-but not the E-Verify system that the president has mandated.
Prudent Steps
Despite such uncertainties, the intensification of immigration enforcement means every contractor should take prudent steps for protection in addition to using E-Verify. Senior management should emphasize that the company will make all reasonable efforts at compliance, documentation, verification and cooperation and will practice active compliance policies at every company location-mere written immigration compliance policies are not enough. Self-audits and the use of outside auditors of a company’s immigration-related hiring practices are essential to avoid ICE search warrants and raids or mitigate their results.
Finally, every company should prepare for the worst case by developing a plan on how to respond to an ICE search warrant or raid. Determine who is responsible for dealing with the lead agent, the targeted employees and the public, and train key staff to implement the plan. All these steps involve time and expense; but the potential problems from heightened immigration enforcement more than justify the effort.
Elise A. Healy, Esq., top attorney in the field of immigration law with Dallas-based Spencer Crain Cubbage Healy & McNamara pllc, represents U.S. and foreign companies, ranging from multinationals to startups, in all types of business immigration matters.
Source URL: https://www.metalconstructionnews.com/articles/troubled-waters-navigating-the-immigration-compliance-minefield/
Copyright ©2026 Metal Construction News unless otherwise noted.