Features

The New Green Roof: Trends in sustainable and green construction increasingly utilize metal, and the perfect complement just might be photovoltaics

By Administrator Green, while certainly a trend in construction, is an extremely vague term that seemingly encompasses every aspect of sustainable and eco-friendly construction operations, processes, components and materials. In terms of metal construction, the actual components and materials used rate highly in many of the most-visible areas used to measure green building products. Metal… Continue reading The New Green Roof: Trends in sustainable and green construction increasingly utilize metal, and the perfect complement just might be photovoltaics
By Administrator

Inovateus-1Green, while certainly a trend in construction, is an extremely vague term that seemingly encompasses every aspect of sustainable and eco-friendly construction operations, processes, components and materials. In terms of metal construction, the actual components and materials used rate highly in many of the most-visible areas used to measure green building products.

Metal can be re-used, is often includes high percentages of recycled content, and the end product can again be recycled. A jobsite featuring substantial metal construction and installation often has very few issues regarding construction waste management, as virtually all the scrap is simply sent to be recycled. The service life of metal construction components is extremely long compared with other traditional products, and metal rtes very well in terms of lifecycle assessments.

But is this leading to an increase in use of metal components?

“A lot of it depends on the know-how, savvy and focus of the owner or designer,” said Thomas Taylor, general manager of Vertegy, a sustainability consultancy firm. “When you get the opportunities to use the product, dismantle it, recycle it very easily, yeah, people tend to move toward using more metal.”

“The one thing I’m still seeing is a knowledge gap between the metal industry and those that are pushing the use of these ‘total lifecycle calculators.’ Because in the lifecycle calculators, the steel buildings do not perform as well as the wood buildings; they perform worse on a pure lifecycle assessment. I think a lot of that is just a lack of good data being provided to those people–the engines that are driving these lifecycle cost calculators,” he added.

Inovateus-2That said, metal products don’t rate highly in a couple of key green areas that are growing in popularity. More and more, communities and states are increasing their code and requirements
(not to mention LED certification) with regard to indigenous construction materials and embodied energy. Many code rating systems are giving/taking away points depending on whether a building material was produced within 300 or 500 miles of the construction site, in an effort to encourage the use of local products and reduce the amount of energy (fuel) used to transport those materials. Metal components don’t score as highly there as often times they are manufactured well beyond the allowable radius and shipped in. On the positive side, metal components are often shipped in via rail as opposed to truck, giving those metal products a slightly better score.

Embodied energy is defined as the commercial energy (generally, fuel) that was used in production make any product, bring it to market, and dispose of it. In this case, steel components are said to have a high embodied energy–certainly higher than something like wood, for example–because of the heat and fuel required to manufacture the product. But, there is a movement to take into account the service life of the product in the lifecycle assessment tools, in which case metal components would obviously score much better.

In terms of getting better scores in the various sustainability assessment software products, Taylor comes back to the idea that some additional effort and education by the steel and metal construction industry would go a long way.

“[Wood buildings] get better numbers; get a better cost. It brings in carbon neutrality, it brings in the resources used to create the product, etc. However, when you look at it, in most uses a steel structure or a steel-reinforced concrete structure stands for many more years than a wood-frame timber structure. I think there’s just been a lack of input from the concrete and steel industries, and because of that, some people are more carbon focused as a guidepost for sustainability and might be steered away from using those products,” he said.

“With regard to [embodied energy], if you look at other things beyond just the resources to create the building product… you look at the longevity of the material; the recyclable nature; the possibility of dismantlement depending on the connection details; the recyclability of the material itself; or the possibility of the reuse of the product without really having to melt it down and having to go into another manufacturing process, the metal structures actually make more sense. But to me there still seems to be a knowledge gap there in the attributes of the steel,” added Taylor.

When looking at additional green trends in metal construction, the actual materials being utilized are often the focus, whether it’s steel, aluminum, zinc, etc. But it appears there’s not a strong trend in any one direction. Certainly there are advancements and innovations in these building materials, for trend-watchers such as Taylor, the potential of any trend lies in the hands of the designer.

“I don’t see any real trends, per se, because it comes down to the desire and the knowledge of the designers more than anything else,” he said. “I can’t say that I’m seeing more of a trend one way or the other. As far as light-gauge steel studs…depending on the size and scale of the project…they’re obviously the mainstay when you get into the larger commercial work.”

“In smaller projects and residential, people are still using wood because of price. The majority of people who are building those structures learned how to do it with wood, so they’re continuing to do that. And part of that is driven by the economy–it’s plentiful and it’s cheap right now. Wood is a commodity, unfortunately. That is the case. If you look at it from a homeowner’s standpoint and when you talk about long-term costs (including insurance costs)…I’m sure most insurance companies would prefer you to use metal framing.”

Inovateus-3Advocating Metal
Again, the running theme in Taylor’s analysis of the role of metal building components in the green building movement, is education and information, whether its architects and designers, developers of lifecycle costing tools, or contractors and owners. Information–the right kind and in the right hands–is key.

“I don’t think there is enough of a partnership between the steel and the metal industry and the people who are writing some of these reports,” he said. “People will say, yeah, look at how much embodied energy it takes to melt that down and recycle it.

OK, then the metal industry needs to spend more time working with the people who have developed these lifecycle cost calculators and these assessment tools, to show them the technology breakthroughs that have been happening. Show them that these metal products aren’t as energy-intensive in the recycling process, as they once were. I think there’s a lot of misconception when it comes to that.”

The steel industry has done a great job in educating particular market areas of the benefits of steel in particular applications, but as steel tries to expand its usage into these emerging markets–namely, green and sustainable–it again finds itself head-to-head with its old foe–wood.

“You have to remember that the timber industry and the soft-wood industry have a very large lobby and there’s more grass-roots efforts there because of the smaller producers,” said Taylor. “They’ve been much more aggressive in working with those who are putting together these assessment tools. I think that if the steel industry would spend more advocacy time dealing with the people from these assessment tool developers, I think that more of the straight story would come out.”

This begs the question: If the education gap was narrowed, would more specifiers use metal more often?
“Yes, I think so,” said Taylor. “In today’s market, that is one trend that I do see, and it’s been going on for a long time. Whatever seems to get the majority of media attention in trade publications and design publications, that’s what we see two months later in building designs.”

“The big buzzword today, at least internationally, is being carbon neutral and carbon offset, etc. And part of that comes back to this whole lifecycle thing. That’s the thing that this demographic that is driving this whole sustainability thing are hanging their hats on.”

While Taylor admits that sustainable and green building projects don’t make up for the downturn the economy has experienced over the last couple years, there does appear to be an increase in these types of projects.

“We’re still seeing a general depression in the general building market in the United States. But the percentage of owners looking at sustainability in terms of overall thought processes and goals is something that we’re seeing being highlighted in the specs in a greater percentage than before we hit the downturn. Before, we were seeing maybe 8-10 percent and it’s definitely higher than that now, maybe approaching 20 percent,” he said.

Inovateus-4Solar Power
Taking into account all of that, the green components or accessories most often mentioned–or the one that seems to receive the lion’s share of attention–are photovoltaics.

Solar and photovoltaics have been popping up more and more on commercial and industrial buildings, thanks in large part to the use of standing seam metal roofing in those projects. The often expansive standing seam metal roofs found on these non-residential buildings are the perfect platform for photovoltaic systems, both crystalline panels and flexible laminates (see sidebars for more), but residential applications have grown relatively slowly. The reason, of course, is price.

“More and more homeowners exploring it,” said Taylor. “In the United States there is still a large stumbling block in front of any type of PV, and that is cost. The willingness is there, technology is picking up where it’s pretty easy to install; it’s not very maintenance intensive. More and more homeowners concerned with their utility bills are investigating it and trying to figure out a way to make it work. I think if it were a little more affordable, or larger amounts of funding dedicated to incentivizing, I think you’d see it a lot more.”

When home owners and developers do choose photovoltaics, the question is crystalline panels, laminates or solar shingles? Until recently, bulky crystalline panels have been the only option, but the combination of increasing interest, developing technology and decreasing costs have opened up the possibilities.

“While the other options are attractive from an esthetics point of view, the crystalline structures are still more efficient,” said Taylor. “Depending on what is driving the decision, that will dictate what you see [in the market].”

As a whole, the market has spoken, and the message is that green building practices are no longer a trend, but a part of today’s intelligent construction practices. Both the residential and non-residential markets want PV technology, and as technologies continue to develop and costs decrease, they’ll get it. Preferably on a metal roof.

Solar Power Case Study
Stanker & Galetto, a general contracting firm in southern New Jersey, completed the installation of a solar energy system on the roof of its Vineland headquarters in June 2009 to demonstrate its commitment to Green Building. Representing a $700,000 investment, the crystalline solar panels used were manufactured by Sharp and supplied by Ray Angelini Inc.

Since installation the solar panels have generated a total of 172,000 kWh of energy, enough to power 13 homes or 1,326 computers for 1 year. The renewable energy provided by the panels avoids the production of harmful greenhouse gases like CO2, NOx, and SO2. To date, the installation has prevented the emission of 289,000 lbs of CO2, 543 lbs of NOx and 795 lbs of SO2 — equal to the pollution an average car emits over 29 years.

Common Questions & Answers About Solar

Q: How much electricity will I get from every kilowatt of solar I install?
A: It depends.” And it depends on a lot of things. Where do you live? How much sun falls where the solar modules will be? Are there trees or other buildings shading your installation any time during the day? What angle will your installation be on? The STC or Standard Test Conditions rating that is applied to solar modules is based on conditions that almost never occur anywhere. Perhaps a few deserts but certainly not your rooftop. Then if you live in someplace like the US where AC power is in use, there are the losses that come from converting the DC power made by the solar modules into the AC you need.

Q: Where can I find out about federal and state incentives?
A:The Database of State Incentives for Renewable Energy
(DSIRE) is a comprehensive source of information on state, local, utility, and federal incentives and policies that promote renewable energy and energy efficiency. Established in 1995, DSIRE is an ongoing project of the NC Solar Center and the Interstate Renewable Energy Council funded by the U.S. Department of Energy.
Source: Inovateus Solar, whose partners include: S-5!, Schneider Electric

Photovoltaic Facts
Photovoltaics (PV) is conversion of light energy into electricity using electronic devices called solar cells. The term “photovoltaics” originated from the combination of the Greek word for light – ‘photos’, and ‘voltaic’ – a reference to Alessandro Volta, an eighteenth century Italian scientist who carried out pioneering work on electricity.

Because the manufacturing costs of PV cells and modules have historically been high, solar energy has been 3-5 times more expensive than energy generated by traditional methods.

Photovoltaic solar cells produce electricity from sunlight. Today, most solar cells are made from rigid multi-crystalline silicon (Si) wafers that are typically 150 µm thick. To create solar cells, these wafers must go through several processing steps and then be integrated into a module. High material and processing costs make Si-based modules relatively expensive.

Thin-film solar cells are potentially lower cost alternatives to Si-based devices because of their comparatively lower processing and materials costs. Thin film solar cells utilize only a 1-4 µm thick layer of semiconducting material to produce electricity. Devices that employ flexible substrates have an additional advantage in advanced applications such as Building Integrated Photovoltaics (“BIPV”) since they can be packaged in flexible and lightweight structures.

Source: SoloPower, whose partners include Centria, MBCI, MFI, McElroy